A Twist on Relationship Violence

How many people have been affected by Ebola in the US this year? Three

How many men have been physically abused by a woman this year? 3.2 million

Recently a dinner conversation with physician friends strayed to Ebola. An ER physician and chairman who oversees a dozen ER’s expressed his frustration at the U.S. Ebola hype. “Why can’t we put this attention toward dog bites? You’re more likely to receive one. And it’s more likely to kill you.”

That got me thinking about unlikely killers in my field.

Think about domestic violence and you think of women, battered by a man in her life. Now, think again.

• 835,000 men are battered by women in the U.S. each year.

• In 2012, 24 percent of U.S. homicides due to domestic violence were men.            

• Of the nine “Most Notorious Crimes of Passion in History,” four were committed by women against men. For example, on 5/28/98, comedian Phil Hartman was shot and killed while he slept by his wife. On 7/4/09, football star Steve McNair was shot and killed by his girlfriend.

In a 2010 review essay in the journal Partner Abuse, the author concluded that women’s motives for domestic violence are often similar to men’s, ranging from anger to coercive control. Not self defense as has previously been assumed.

Making things worse, men often suffer physical abuse in silence as they feel less manly for “allowing” themselves to be abused. They are afraid no one will take them seriously. Unfortunately with good reason.

Denise Hines of Clark University found that when an abused man called the police, the police were more likely to arrest him than his female partner. When men tried calling domestic-violence hot lines, 64 percent were told the hot lines helped only women.

I emphasize this not to undermine the real horror of domestic violence against women or the epidemic in Africa.

I emphasize this to keep a very real problem from slipping into the shadow of larger or hyped-up problems.

But men also have to help themselves:

Men have to take this seriously. In one survey of college students, 20 percent of men who had been attacked by their girlfriends thought it was “funny.” Violence that seems harmless at first can escalate.

Men have to stand up for themselves. The first time she hits you, tell her that if there's a second time, it will be the last time she sees you—and act on it.

Men have to control themselves. Don't hit back. Men can typically do more damage with a single blow and then that will take the spotlight. (Think Ray Rice).

Men must speak up. If you cannot easily leave (because of the children, for example) let someone know what is happening. Overcome the embarrassment and call the police. Talk to a counselor, your doctor, family members.

And women, if we are going to insist men control themselves, let us take our own advice. Let’s prove we can close the gender gap in leadership while not closing it in relationship violence as well. 

Last modified on
Rate this item
(0 votes)
Laura F. Dabney , M.D.

Laura F. Dabney, M.D., trained at Eastern Virginia Medical School and practiced emergency, in-patient and consult-liaison psychiatry at all the area hospitals including Sentara Norfolk General and the Veteran’s Hospital in Hampton. As a doctor of psychiatry, she treats patients with medication as well as all of today’s popular therapy techniques. As a physician, she can figure out if your symptoms are due to a medical or an emotional problem. Many medical problems, such as hypothyroidism, can cause emotional symptoms and thus be mistaken for a psychiatric problem. A medical background provides Dr. Dabney with the ability to give you an accurate, safe diagnosis. Dr. Dabney keeps up to date with her medical training as a member of various professional organizations. For more information, visit www.drldabney.com, call 757-340-0800, or email dabneyoffice@gmail.com.

back to top

Explore More From Women’s Health

Nitrous Oxide as Pain Relief in Labor

Nitrous Oxide as Pain Relief in Labor

Women’s Health 07-01-2020

Is nitrous oxide a safe pain reliever during labor? Read more

Pregnancy and COVID-19

Pregnancy and COVID-19

Women’s Health 06-01-2020

Read about ACOG advisories for pregnant women during the pandemic. Read more

Low-Dose Aspirin in Pregnancy

Low-Dose Aspirin in Pregnancy

Women’s Health 05-01-2020

Ask your provider if low-dose aspirin will ensure a healthier pregnancy. Read more

11 Tips to Quit Smoking

11 Tips to Quit Smoking

Longevity 04-01-2020

Start by committing yourself fully and then make a plan. Read more

The First Annual Birth Control

The First Annual Birth Control

Women’s Health 04-01-2020

Enjoy the freedom of Annovera, an easy-to-use annual contraceptive. Read more

Endometriosis Awareness Months

Endometriosis Awareness Months

Women’s Health 03-01-2020

Get the latest scoop on treatments for this painful disorder. Read more

Eating Disorders in Pregnancy

Eating Disorders in Pregnancy

Women’s Health 02-01-2020

Read this to find out why pregnant women with eating disorders have to be extra-vigilant. Read more

Healthy Eyes and Ears

Healthy Eyes and Ears

Longevity 01-02-2020

Don’t let vision and/or hearing loss slow you down. Read more

Management of Abnormal Pap Tests

Management of Abnormal Pap Tests

Women’s Health 01-01-2020

Follow-up testing is crucial for women with a history of abnormal pap tests. Read more